Short field or soft field – So what ?
Take offs and landing from grass runways require special technique and not all pilots are comfortable with that. Take-off at very low speed followed by acceleration in ground effect or approaches and landing with higher than usual nose-up attitude can seem impressive and require some training. I don’t have this problem. Not that I’m a better pilots than everyone else, but because I learned to fly on a 800 meters / 2600 feet long grass runway. Both thresholds were displaced, and the shortest landing distance was 520 meters / 1700 feet.
Is that short ? It certainly depends where you use to fly. I reckon to most US standards, this is short. I learned to fly in this environment where landing shortly after threshold and with accurate speed is important. Not that landing long on a 12.000 feet runway is good or acceptable, but it’s much less drama. The first time I landed on the main runway which is 12.000 feet long and concrete, I flared to high because of the well known optical illusions. My instructor was here and corrected for that. I learned to adapt my flare to larger runways, but my primary one remains soft and short making soft and short landings and take-offs non-events for me.
Similar considerations apply for different domains as well. I feel at home at controlled airports, and in low-wing tricylce aircraft. I have some experience in high-wing aircraft, none with tail wheel, and I’m not so used to navigate VFR “clock-and-compass” over flat land without major landmarks. Just like each pilot, I’ve my strengths and my weaknesses and I think it’s important to know them. I continue to extend my comfort zone, step by step. Sometimes with an instructor, sometimes alone on board. The place where I learned to fly the DA42 has more often crosswinds than Geneva, where the winds are almost always in the axis because of the surrounding mountains.
The pilot certificate is a license to learn, and we should never stop exercising these priviledges. The Flying Across America adventure I’m preparing for next year will certainly be a great opportunity to learn new things, in a completely new context. Not tail wheel or sea plane though… this will have to wait a bit.







4 Comments, Comment or Ping
Matthew Stibbe
I fly a Cirrus SR22 out of Denham, England. It has a 2100′ runway and a 4 degree glideslope to get over some trees. It seems routine for me to land on such as short runway but I occasionally speak to other pilots in the US who find it astonishing. I guess practice and familiarity make things easier.
Oct 11th, 2009
Sylvia
I flared too high because of the well known optical illusions
Was this Lausanne? I still haven’t forgiven myself for screwing that one up even AFTER you’d warned me in detail!
Oct 23rd, 2009
Vincent
@Sylvia: this was Geneva. Changing from 27 meters wide grass strip to the 54 meters wide main concrete runway… exactly twice as wide.
Oct 24th, 2009
Sylvia
Ah yes, that would cause issues!
Oct 24th, 2009
Reply to “Short field or soft field – So what ?”